The Impact of Rodriguez v. FCA on CA Lemon Law

Purchasing a used car can be an economical choice, but it’s important to understand the protections available to you as a consumer. In California, the Lemon Law provides safeguards for buyers against defective vehicles. However, not all used cars qualify under this law, as clarified by the Rodriguez v. FCA case. This blog post will explore the implications of this case and what it means for consumers buying used cars in California.

Background: California Lemon Law

The California Lemon Law, officially known as the Song-Beverly Consumer Warranty Act, is designed to protect consumers who purchase or lease new vehicles with substantial defects. Under this law, if the manufacturer can’t fix a covered defect within a reasonable number of attempts, they must either replace or repurchase the vehicle. This law traditionally covered new vehicles and, in some cases, used vehicles still under the original manufacturer’s warranty.

The Rodriguez v. FCA Case: A Closer Look

In the case of Rodriguez v. FCA, the court specifically addressed the issue of whether the California Lemon Law applies to used vehicles that are not certified or not covered by the original manufacturer’s warranty. The plaintiff, Rodriguez, had purchased a used vehicle that later exhibited several defects. When the manufacturer refused to repurchase the vehicle, Rodriguez filed a lawsuit under the California Lemon Law.

The court ultimately ruled that the California Lemon Law does not extend to used vehicles unless they are certified pre-owned (CPO) or still under the original manufacturer’s warranty. This decision clarified that buyers of non-certified used cars without an active manufacturer’s warranty do not have the same protections under this specific law.

Implications for Used Car Buyers

  1. Certified Pre-Owned Vehicles: If you’re buying a used car and want the protection of the California Lemon Law, consider a certified pre-owned vehicle from an authorized dealer. These vehicles typically come with a manufacturer’s warranty, which could bring them under the purview of the Lemon Law.
  2. Non-Certified Used Vehicles: If you’re purchasing a non-certified used car without a manufacturer’s warranty, understand that the California Lemon Law likely does not cover you. However, other protections, such as the implied warranty of merchantability under the Uniform Commercial Code, may still apply.
  3. Thorough Inspection: Since non-CPO used cars are not covered, it’s crucial to have the vehicle thoroughly inspected by a trusted mechanic before purchase to uncover any potential issues.
  4. Dealer Warranties: Some used car dealers may offer their warranties. Understand what these cover and for how long, but remember these are not the same as the manufacturer’s warranty and don’t provide Lemon Law protections.
  5. Legal Advice: If you’re unsure about the coverage or your rights, consult with a legal professional specializing in consumer protection and lemon law. They can provide advice based on the specifics of your situation.

Navigating Your Used Car Purchase

The Rodriguez v. FCA case has significant implications for used car buyers in California, underscoring the importance of understanding what protections are available under the state’s Lemon Law. When buying a used vehicle, consider whether it’s certified pre-owned. Always conduct thorough research and inspections, understand any warranties offered, and seek professional advice when necessary. By taking these steps, you can make a more informed decision and navigate your used car purchase with confidence.

Free Case Evaluation

DISCLAIMER - I understand that I am only requesting a free evaluation, and that by doing so Pro Attorneys and I are not creating a business or legal relationship between us. This will only happen if we both agree to this later.